{ "study": "BI-01-RA1", "status": "Derived finite-model sensitivity; not clinical or empirical evidence", "parameters": { "base": "2/5", "outcome_pay": "1/5", "q": "1/2", "d": "4/5", "f": "1/10", "Kmax": "1/5", "epsilon": "1/100", "review_cost": "1/20", "current_budget": "3/4", "success_probabilities": { "E": { "low": "4/5", "high": "19/20" }, "H": { "low": "2/5", "high": "3/5" } }, "effort_cost": { "low": "3/10", "high": "2/5" } }, "checks_by_group": { "independent_event_tree": 900, "exact_frontier": 30, "endpoint_ties": 10, "correct_control": 48, "unbounded_flag": 1, "original_model_reproduced": 10, "nested_lambda_one": 7, "nested_lambda_one_tie": 1, "aggregate_calibration": 2, "aggregate_counterexample": 4, "aggregate_frontier": 8, "action_conditioning_diagnostic": 2, "positive_margin_needed": 3 }, "scenarios": [ { "scenario": "original_raw", "lambda": "1", "K": "1/5", "benchmark_rule": "fixed_before_choice", "benchmark_E": "9/10", "benchmark_H": "9/10", "review_known": false, "action_centered": false, "tied_policies": 1, "policy": 0, "states": [ { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "1/2", "weight": "1/2", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "9/10" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "1/2", "weight": "1/2", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "9/10" } ], "completion": "1", "success_per_eligible": "31/40", "success_among_completed": "31/40", "residual_per_eligible": "-1/8", "residual_among_completed": "-1/8", "provider_utility": "33/400", "current_spending": "29/50", "effort_resource_cost": "2/5", "false_loss_per_eligible": "1/100", "enrollment_feasible": true, "current_budget_feasible": true }, { "scenario": "original_raw", "lambda": "1", "K": "1/5", "benchmark_rule": "fixed_before_choice", "benchmark_E": "9/10", "benchmark_H": "9/10", "review_known": true, "action_centered": false, "tied_policies": 1, "policy": 0, "states": [ { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "0", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "9/10" }, { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "1", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "9/10" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "0", "weight": "1/4", "action": "withhold", "benchmark_used": null }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "1", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "9/10" } ], "completion": "3/4", "success_per_eligible": "5/8", "success_among_completed": "5/6", "residual_per_eligible": "-1/20", "residual_among_completed": "-1/15", "provider_utility": "9/100", "current_spending": "9/20", "effort_resource_cost": "3/10", "false_loss_per_eligible": "1/100", "enrollment_feasible": true, "current_budget_feasible": true }, { "scenario": "correct_high_reference", "lambda": "1", "K": "1/5", "benchmark_rule": "fixed_before_choice", "benchmark_E": "19/20", "benchmark_H": "3/5", "review_known": false, "action_centered": false, "tied_policies": 1, "policy": 0, "states": [ { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "1/2", "weight": "1/2", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "19/20" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "1/2", "weight": "1/2", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "3/5" } ], "completion": "1", "success_per_eligible": "31/40", "success_among_completed": "31/40", "residual_per_eligible": "0", "residual_among_completed": "0", "provider_utility": "29/200", "current_spending": "29/50", "effort_resource_cost": "2/5", "false_loss_per_eligible": "1/100", "enrollment_feasible": true, "current_budget_feasible": true }, { "scenario": "correct_high_reference", "lambda": "1", "K": "1/5", "benchmark_rule": "fixed_before_choice", "benchmark_E": "19/20", "benchmark_H": "3/5", "review_known": true, "action_centered": false, "tied_policies": 1, "policy": 0, "states": [ { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "0", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "19/20" }, { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "1", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "19/20" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "0", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "3/5" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "1", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "3/5" } ], "completion": "1", "success_per_eligible": "31/40", "success_among_completed": "31/40", "residual_per_eligible": "0", "residual_among_completed": "0", "provider_utility": "29/200", "current_spending": "29/50", "effort_resource_cost": "2/5", "false_loss_per_eligible": "1/100", "enrollment_feasible": true, "current_budget_feasible": true }, { "scenario": "half_original_bias", "lambda": "1", "K": "1/5", "benchmark_rule": "fixed_before_choice", "benchmark_E": "37/40", "benchmark_H": "3/4", "review_known": false, "action_centered": false, "tied_policies": 1, "policy": 0, "states": [ { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "1/2", "weight": "1/2", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "37/40" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "1/2", "weight": "1/2", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "3/4" } ], "completion": "1", "success_per_eligible": "31/40", "success_among_completed": "31/40", "residual_per_eligible": "-1/16", "residual_among_completed": "-1/16", "provider_utility": "91/800", "current_spending": "29/50", "effort_resource_cost": "2/5", "false_loss_per_eligible": "1/100", "enrollment_feasible": true, "current_budget_feasible": true }, { "scenario": "half_original_bias", "lambda": "1", "K": "1/5", "benchmark_rule": "fixed_before_choice", "benchmark_E": "37/40", "benchmark_H": "3/4", "review_known": true, "action_centered": false, "tied_policies": 1, "policy": 0, "states": [ { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "0", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "37/40" }, { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "1", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "37/40" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "0", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "3/4" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "1", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "3/4" } ], "completion": "1", "success_per_eligible": "31/40", "success_among_completed": "31/40", "residual_per_eligible": "-1/16", "residual_among_completed": "-1/16", "provider_utility": "91/800", "current_spending": "29/50", "effort_resource_cost": "2/5", "false_loss_per_eligible": "1/100", "enrollment_feasible": true, "current_budget_feasible": true }, { "scenario": "bias_threshold_tie", "lambda": "1", "K": "1/5", "benchmark_rule": "fixed_before_choice", "benchmark_E": "91/100", "benchmark_H": "21/25", "review_known": false, "action_centered": false, "tied_policies": 1, "policy": 0, "states": [ { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "1/2", "weight": "1/2", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "91/100" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "1/2", "weight": "1/2", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "21/25" } ], "completion": "1", "success_per_eligible": "31/40", "success_among_completed": "31/40", "residual_per_eligible": "-1/10", "residual_among_completed": "-1/10", "provider_utility": "19/200", "current_spending": "29/50", "effort_resource_cost": "2/5", "false_loss_per_eligible": "1/100", "enrollment_feasible": true, "current_budget_feasible": true }, { "scenario": "bias_threshold_tie", "lambda": "1", "K": "1/5", "benchmark_rule": "fixed_before_choice", "benchmark_E": "91/100", "benchmark_H": "21/25", "review_known": true, "action_centered": false, "tied_policies": 2, "policy": 0, "states": [ { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "0", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "91/100" }, { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "1", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "91/100" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "0", "weight": "1/4", "action": "withhold", "benchmark_used": null }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "1", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "21/25" } ], "completion": "3/4", "success_per_eligible": "5/8", "success_among_completed": "5/6", "residual_per_eligible": "-1/25", "residual_among_completed": "-4/75", "provider_utility": "19/200", "current_spending": "9/20", "effort_resource_cost": "3/10", "false_loss_per_eligible": "1/100", "enrollment_feasible": true, "current_budget_feasible": true }, { "scenario": "bias_threshold_tie", "lambda": "1", "K": "1/5", "benchmark_rule": "fixed_before_choice", "benchmark_E": "91/100", "benchmark_H": "21/25", "review_known": true, "action_centered": false, "tied_policies": 2, "policy": 1, "states": [ { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "0", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "91/100" }, { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "1", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "91/100" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "0", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "21/25" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "1", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "21/25" } ], "completion": "1", "success_per_eligible": "31/40", "success_among_completed": "31/40", "residual_per_eligible": "-1/10", "residual_among_completed": "-1/10", "provider_utility": "19/200", "current_spending": "29/50", "effort_resource_cost": "2/5", "false_loss_per_eligible": "1/100", "enrollment_feasible": true, "current_budget_feasible": true }, { "scenario": "ninety_percent_bias", "lambda": "1", "K": "1/5", "benchmark_rule": "fixed_before_choice", "benchmark_E": "181/200", "benchmark_H": "87/100", "review_known": false, "action_centered": false, "tied_policies": 1, "policy": 0, "states": [ { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "1/2", "weight": "1/2", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "181/200" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "1/2", "weight": "1/2", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "87/100" } ], "completion": "1", "success_per_eligible": "31/40", "success_among_completed": "31/40", "residual_per_eligible": "-9/80", "residual_among_completed": "-9/80", "provider_utility": "71/800", "current_spending": "29/50", "effort_resource_cost": "2/5", "false_loss_per_eligible": "1/100", "enrollment_feasible": true, "current_budget_feasible": true }, { "scenario": "ninety_percent_bias", "lambda": "1", "K": "1/5", "benchmark_rule": "fixed_before_choice", "benchmark_E": "181/200", "benchmark_H": "87/100", "review_known": true, "action_centered": false, "tied_policies": 1, "policy": 0, "states": [ { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "0", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "181/200" }, { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "1", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "181/200" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "0", "weight": "1/4", "action": "withhold", "benchmark_used": null }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "1", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "87/100" } ], "completion": "3/4", "success_per_eligible": "5/8", "success_among_completed": "5/6", "residual_per_eligible": "-9/200", "residual_among_completed": "-3/50", "provider_utility": "37/400", "current_spending": "9/20", "effort_resource_cost": "3/10", "false_loss_per_eligible": "1/100", "enrollment_feasible": true, "current_budget_feasible": true }, { "scenario": "aggregate_calibrated_subgroup_error", "lambda": "2", "K": "1/5", "benchmark_rule": "fixed_before_choice", "benchmark_E": "4/5", "benchmark_H": "3/4", "review_known": false, "action_centered": false, "tied_policies": 1, "policy": 0, "states": [ { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "1/2", "weight": "1/2", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "4/5" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "1/2", "weight": "1/2", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "3/4" } ], "completion": "1", "success_per_eligible": "31/40", "success_among_completed": "31/40", "residual_per_eligible": "0", "residual_among_completed": "0", "provider_utility": "29/200", "current_spending": "29/50", "effort_resource_cost": "2/5", "false_loss_per_eligible": "1/100", "enrollment_feasible": true, "current_budget_feasible": true }, { "scenario": "aggregate_calibrated_subgroup_error", "lambda": "2", "K": "1/5", "benchmark_rule": "fixed_before_choice", "benchmark_E": "4/5", "benchmark_H": "3/4", "review_known": true, "action_centered": false, "tied_policies": 1, "policy": 0, "states": [ { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "0", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "4/5" }, { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "1", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "4/5" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "0", "weight": "1/4", "action": "withhold", "benchmark_used": null }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "1", "weight": "1/4", "action": "high", "benchmark_used": "3/4" } ], "completion": "3/4", "success_per_eligible": "5/8", "success_among_completed": "5/6", "residual_per_eligible": "3/80", "residual_among_completed": "1/20", "provider_utility": "61/400", "current_spending": "9/20", "effort_resource_cost": "3/10", "false_loss_per_eligible": "1/100", "enrollment_feasible": true, "current_budget_feasible": true }, { "scenario": "action_conditioned_diagnostic", "lambda": "1", "K": "1/5", "benchmark_rule": "action_specific_probability", "benchmark_E": null, "benchmark_H": null, "review_known": false, "action_centered": true, "tied_policies": 1, "policy": 0, "states": [ { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "1/2", "weight": "1/2", "action": "low", "benchmark_used": "4/5" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "1/2", "weight": "1/2", "action": "low", "benchmark_used": "2/5" } ], "completion": "1", "success_per_eligible": "3/5", "success_among_completed": "3/5", "residual_per_eligible": "0", "residual_among_completed": "0", "provider_utility": "21/100", "current_spending": "109/200", "effort_resource_cost": "3/10", "false_loss_per_eligible": "1/100", "enrollment_feasible": true, "current_budget_feasible": true }, { "scenario": "action_conditioned_diagnostic", "lambda": "1", "K": "1/5", "benchmark_rule": "action_specific_probability", "benchmark_E": null, "benchmark_H": null, "review_known": true, "action_centered": true, "tied_policies": 1, "policy": 0, "states": [ { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "0", "weight": "1/4", "action": "low", "benchmark_used": "4/5" }, { "group": "E", "review_probability_at_choice": "1", "weight": "1/4", "action": "low", "benchmark_used": "4/5" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "0", "weight": "1/4", "action": "low", "benchmark_used": "2/5" }, { "group": "H", "review_probability_at_choice": "1", "weight": "1/4", "action": "low", "benchmark_used": "2/5" } ], "completion": "1", "success_per_eligible": "3/5", "success_among_completed": "3/5", "residual_per_eligible": "0", "residual_among_completed": "0", "provider_utility": "21/100", "current_spending": "109/200", "effort_resource_cost": "3/10", "false_loss_per_eligible": "1/100", "enrollment_feasible": true, "current_budget_feasible": true } ], "nested_frontiers": [ { "theta": "0", "benchmark_E": "19/20", "benchmark_H": "3/5", "unknown_weak_max_lambda": null, "known_weak_max_lambda": null, "unbounded": true, "finite_endpoints_have_ties": false }, { "theta": "1/10", "benchmark_E": "189/200", "benchmark_H": "63/100", "unknown_weak_max_lambda": "38/3", "known_weak_max_lambda": "8", "unbounded": false, "finite_endpoints_have_ties": true }, { "theta": "1/4", "benchmark_E": "15/16", "benchmark_H": "27/40", "unknown_weak_max_lambda": "76/15", "known_weak_max_lambda": "16/5", "unbounded": false, "finite_endpoints_have_ties": true }, { "theta": "1/2", "benchmark_E": "37/40", "benchmark_H": "3/4", "unknown_weak_max_lambda": "38/15", "known_weak_max_lambda": "8/5", "unbounded": false, "finite_endpoints_have_ties": true }, { "theta": "4/5", "benchmark_E": "91/100", "benchmark_H": "21/25", "unknown_weak_max_lambda": "19/12", "known_weak_max_lambda": "1", "unbounded": false, "finite_endpoints_have_ties": true }, { "theta": "9/10", "benchmark_E": "181/200", "benchmark_H": "87/100", "unknown_weak_max_lambda": "38/27", "known_weak_max_lambda": "8/9", "unbounded": false, "finite_endpoints_have_ties": true }, { "theta": "1", "benchmark_E": "9/10", "benchmark_H": "9/10", "unknown_weak_max_lambda": "19/15", "known_weak_max_lambda": "4/5", "unbounded": false, "finite_endpoints_have_ties": true } ], "source_sha256": "1fa80c10dc978a2b3cdf4369489880be200527db81158bfa1a093d5793a869df" }